F*ggot As Gender Identity, Detransition As A Form Of Suicide.

28 Sep

“I shall never forget the unspeakable horror that froze the lymph in my glands when the baneful word seared my reeling brain – I was a homosexual. I thought of the painted, simpering female impersonators I had seen in a Baltimore nightclub. Could it be possible I was one of those subhuman things? I walked the streets in a daze, like a man with a light concussion. I would have destroyed myself but a wise old queen; Bobo, we called her,taught me that I had a duty to live and to bear my burden proudly for all to see.” – William Burroughs


I’ve brought it up a few times, but I grew up Assemblies Of God and went Southern Baptist at 12 because they were more liberal. I’m not even building up to a joke here. In any case, attending huge tent revivals was a common occurrence throughout my entire childhood and adolescence. You’d be lectured for an hour and then people would stand in line for several more hours to repent, to publicly beat at their chest and renounce all their sins and reaffirm their devotion to God or whatever.

Watch enough of them and you’d see repeat performers… folks that had suddenly hit a brand new rock bottom of fornication and decadence or whatever and would be up front with the others, beating their chest and confessing to increasingly absurd transgressions against their fellow man.

This is relevant probably.

Anyway, you waste enough time on the transgender corner of the internet and eventually you start stumbling across detransition blogs. They’re always anonymous, declaring an unnamed dread of being discovered by this shapeless mob of “trans activists” out to ruin their lives for telling “the truth”. There’s this flair for the dramatic amongst the conspiracies and the increasingly absurd confessions of transgressions; this idea that the curtain is being drawn on “what the trans activists don’t want you to hear”.  faggot3

What they all have in common is an assurance that they know what they are now. Many claim to be gay men, but others actually claim to have discovered with horror that they were autogynephiles the whole time. Seriously. I personally know at least half a dozen funny, sweet and brilliant trans women that have all killed themselves this year before they’d barely started their twenties and yet some pathetic porn-sick creatures can read the documentation on what autogynephilia is, decide “well hot damn that totally describes me” and somehow not feel inspired to stick their head in the oven. This is why I know there is no God.

I any case, I don’t claim to know shit. I don’t have any answer as to who or what I am and am not really sure there is such an answer. I don’t “identify as a woman”, whatever that means, but have experience a lifelong disassociation and revulsion towards being socially processed through “manhood”. This has meant quite a few different things in my life, mostly because I had no language to describe or understand it.

meyoung2And I’ve been dealing with this for decades.

The thing is, I wasn’t really processed through “manhood”, at least not in the sense of being socialized like a heteronormative hegemonic man (as if there was such a thing in a universal sense). From a very young age I was coded by society as a “faggot”, and my socialization was filtered through that coding. I was groomed towards appeasement and subservience to men and coded as deserving of violence and marginalization without resource for complaint. I was groomed to desire approval from and to appeal towards masculine idealizations, while also being held at arms length from any chance of owning them.

I’ve been a eunuch my whole life, regardless of whether I had balls. Faggot was my “gender identity”.

gendercrit25Reminder that “TERF is a slur” but faggot is a radfem-endorsed social identity.

Anyway, a little over a decade ago, I was coerced into detransition by my radical feminist-devoted boyfriend at the time. He was my second (and second longest) relationship I’ve ever had. I loved him like crazy; hell, I still do. He was brilliant and wordly and passionate, had impeccable music and artistic taste, and he fucked like a goddamn howitzer. True story: the first time we fucked, it was to the Mindless Self-Indulgence Song “Faggot“.

I have no pics of us then, so here’s one from 2006. Yes I’m still friends with him.

But he was also a verbally abusive alcoholic that used to tell me shit like “you’re not a woman; you’re a guy that I fuck in the ass and I wish you’d just accept that”. I wrote about it in my comic, but have never until now included the last page online because it was too painful:



Where was the Trans Cabal during all this? The one that is supposedly out there pressuring all the gender non-conforming people to transition? Oh right, they were too busy not existing.

gendercrit20well, besides existing in the imaginations of transphobic gaybros

But how did I get to that point anyway? Well, nobody gives a shit about tired old stories of pre-teen crossdressing and childhood dreams of being able to break my dick off like a pencil so I could stop fretting about it or whatever. Stories of shoplifting lipstick and a hollowed out teddy bear full of stockings and skirts. Boring shit that folks always trot out their own variation of. Nobody cares.

I feel it’s worth repeating tho that literally the first thing I bought with my own money (earned from my job in the dorm cafeteria) when I’d moved away from family to go to college was a (truly hideous) dress and some (appallingly cheap) makeup.

18yearoldmeNo pic of that either, so here’s me at legendary punk club Einsteins in 1995.

I didn’t really have the language to understand what the hell was going on tho. “Transgender” wasn’t really a word I had back then, and I don’t recall whether I’d used “transsexual” either. In college I’d read “Transsexual Empire” and it’s spiritual sister book “The Pink Swastika” and similar anti-gay books, seemingly most from the 80s. This was literally the only literature on the subject available in a college library in the 1990s. So I became one of those late-90s internet-addicted transsexuals one reads about. Still have my copy of Creating A Feminine Carriage and Melanie Speaks circa-1999 to prove it.

90stranssexualSays a lot that I held onto both through a decade of detransition, really.

Back then I still had no idea how to, like, be trans tho. I was a semi-professional drag queen, which gave me a place to explore presentation and also offered me a place to meet men that could potentially find me desirable. I ordered crap fake hormones from crossdresser magazines to bolster the hardcore hormones I was buying from drag queens that snuck them up from Mexico.

Me at infamous Killeen drag bar Krossover, circa 2000-ish

But, like, I knew I was something different than a drag queen, but what? I attended transsexual support meetings full of sneering old ladies sitting bolt upright with their purses in their laps. Women that wrinkled their noses at my leather jacket and Walgreens lipstick, called me “drag queen” and “misguided faggot” behind my back. Hell I didn’t even know if I “wanted to be a woman”, whatever that meant. For the majority of my transition, I only knew one other trans woman that didn’t despise me. And because my life is a fucking disaster, I wound up dating her after detransition.

faggot5Even more awkward, now she’s a guy again and thinks I’m disgusting.

To add further insult to injury, I’d met an actual trans activist (Ann Tagonist) shortly before my detransition, and she couldn’t help me. She actually recognized me from my tattoos related to my gender-angst comic Why I’m Not An Artist, which she’d read at a zine library in Portland. We were pen pals for about a year then lost contact anti-climactically. The universe loves to fuck with me.

I remember someone asking me, after hearing about my detransition, “So you pursued a sex change and gave up; what does that make you now?”. Honestly, I had no clue.

After detransition I figured if I had to be a guy, I might as well have some fun with it. I embraced absurd, flamboyant male dressings; arrow collars and exotic suit jackets and such. My gender identity was Nikki Sixx from Motley Crue.


I figured folks that had known me for so long would have gotten the joke; this over-the-top expression of rock star masculine swagger I’d suddenly adopted. Nobody got the joke. Hell, after long enough, I’d lost the plot so much I wasn’t getting it either.

A funny thing about being a dude when you don’t want to be; you can deliberately kill yourself slowly in front of everyone and get cheered on for it. You can drink to the point where your skin is flushed from puking and pick up another drink while sobbing about your childhood and everyone just pats you on the back and is like “wow that dude is a party animal”. If you’re charming and funny enough, nobody questions your judgement. I’ve had dudes tell me how “dramatic” I became post-transition, and it’s like “wait, you fucking saw me smash a whiskey bottle and cut myself in public once because I was sad pre-transition”.

 faggot1yeah this dude had it all together and wasn’t literally imploding in on himself

Detransition was the worst fucking thing that ever happened to me. I regret it every day; dwelling on how I already knew things about myself and worked on them and then gave up. I was a coward and a failure and pathetic for doing it.

And yet going back to that misery is constantly advocated to me and folks like me.

yeragayman“you’re not a woman; you’re a guy that I fuck in the ass…”

Let’s not fucking pretend what people really mean when the push for this is “hurry the fuck up and die and get out of my way”. Because that is what detransitioning again would do to me. And I guess the universe isn’t done fucking with me yet.


23 Responses to “F*ggot As Gender Identity, Detransition As A Form Of Suicide.”

  1. Cheryl Ann Wright September 28, 2014 at 6:47 am #

    We all have our own crosses to bare… we all have lessons to teach some one else… we have people we need to and or have to minister to….please a life is to live… I am a transgender and I came out to family a while back and this week will be coming out to everyone else friends and neighbors talking to them one at a time… I feel great to be a woman I do not consider myself trans I just think of myself as a woman…. I was born with male genitalia but I am 100% wooman

  2. Demonsquirrel September 28, 2014 at 12:44 pm #

    Oh, honey….. I hate what the gender binary straitjacket squishes us into. I wish for you a safe place where you could figure out who feels right to be _you_ without any pressure to be male or female. If you end up one or the other or just genderqueer/non-binary, as long as you feel you in your own skin…. that’s what’s important.

    Fuck every single person who tells you that you ‘have’ to be any specific gender to make THEM happy. Burn them in a supernova. And just listen to you.

    Many many jedi hugs offered.

  3. scarletnbloom September 28, 2014 at 12:47 pm #

    *offers big hugs* soooooooooooo many feels on this.

    God, the bit about slowly killing yourself in front of everybody really hits home for me. I remember one clip of reality from a blackout bender where I was having sex and being choked and LITERALLY BEGGED FOR THEM TO KILL ME.


    I love you and I’ve never even met you in person. You are a beautiful and thoughtful and caring and hilarious and genuine human being. Thank you for being you and showing me it’s okay to be me.

  4. Emily September 28, 2014 at 3:41 pm #

    I love you Rani, I almost feel a little like a kindred spirit in some respects. My family doesn’t get my transition, I also “still look like (insert whatever you would like to guess my old name is here).” Yet they never give me the chance to express myself completely around them. Not that it would make much difference. I was a Goth before, and I am still a Goth now, all skulls, boots and floor length trench coats. I’d love to try and experiment with make up, even if to just explore how to make myself less “male” looking but I am not even permitted to wear what I want around my family.

  5. Amy Feral September 28, 2014 at 5:32 pm #

    I love you more than life.
    I’ve loved you &I’ve known who you are, balls to bone, down in the deepest center of my SELF, regardless of whate ever gender, or lack thereof, you’ve chosen to represent yourself as. The day we went back to where you, “played with wind. It was my true,& only friend who understood me, as I lay in the tall tall grass didn’t even realize there were things such things as ‘woman’ & ‘man’, I was so young”. The day we spoke so little, yet exchanged more info about each other than we ever could with spoken word. I never met anyone else who played with wind besides myself.
    I will ALWAYS remember that day in the middle of nowhere. The drive there & back. Seeing where you used to live( so *isolated*
    from any neighbhors ) your gradeschool, the library your mother took you&your brother to.
    For the first time in my life, a certain part of me Id ALWAYS felt lonely, YOU MADE ME FEEL LESS ALONE.

  6. Amy Feral September 28, 2014 at 5:37 pm #

    Sorry, abt the msg, my ph won’t doesn’t wk well…
    I love you,& all I mean? You’re you, you’ve always been. No matter what you represented yourself as. Gender-wise or otherwise. You are you!
    Thank you for that day. I have since never felt alone. There is no language to describe either of us. All I can say, for the bajillionth time

  7. Amy Feral September 28, 2014 at 5:43 pm #

    P.S. I got the joke silly. It’s exactly *our* sense of humor. I got the joke so strongly I cried on the plane home.

  8. Pam Harrison September 29, 2014 at 10:06 am #

    What a sad, sad story 😦

  9. Chris September 29, 2014 at 8:19 pm #

    Binary gender identity is NOT a universal constant, plenty of other cultures that were more accepting of others. Hopefully one day we can get there again. I can’t and I won’t assume I know who somebody is or why they do what they do. Your identity is your own, no matter how much others try to fit you in their categories.

  10. Caryn LeMur October 1, 2014 at 2:25 pm #

    During my chaotic thought times, I stumbled across ‘Gender Outlaw’ and devoured that book. If gender identity is binary, this book made it a continuum with lots of great places inbetween. Even more interesting, if gender identity is a continuum, this book made you realize it may be an open set of possibilities – three dimensions.

    I was free to transition in any direction.

    I also do hear you about the cost of transitioning… I do not think I could survive a de-transitioning. Just changing once (transitioning) cost me so many things internally and externally. I like where I am at… and it is nice to be in a good harbor.

    Hugs! hang in there! Your art comic skills are wonderful, btw.

    Blessings! Caryn

    • Amy Feral October 1, 2014 at 2:33 pm #

      Honey, I’m sorry I can’t relate but intellectually the physical side of what you’re going through.
      I was just explaining I love you for you,& call it “binary” or whatever. I’ve ALWAYS related to you that way. Without the language. You know I have my own issue w not fitting into either neat lil box of gender. I never have.

  11. TED YING November 3, 2015 at 5:23 am #

    Practical ideas . I Appreciate the analysis – Does someone know where I might access a sample Crossdresser Magazines example to use ?

  12. Mocha Jones August 29, 2017 at 3:49 am #

    You have many issues that you need to talk to with a therapist. That’s quite apparent from your post.

    Detransitioning without getting through your underlying neuroses is like trying to put the roof on your house before there are any walls.

    If your boyfriend thought you didn’t show characteristics of being a woman, then there’s probably something to that.

    • .geist. August 29, 2017 at 1:50 pm #

      How about you fuck off??


  1. There’s A New Racist Violent Fake-Intersex Gendercrit Trans In Town, And He’s Gonna Make Us Pay. | Rani Bakr Digs You. - May 23, 2015

    […] I’ve probably said a billion times that I wasn’t far off from becoming gendercrit when I detransitioned a decade […]

  2. A Master-Post Of Gendercrits Appealing to The Homophobic Religious Right #TERF #TERFLogic | Rani Bakr Digs You. - June 2, 2015

    […] me as claiming to be lesbian (which I never have) and insisting that I’m a heterosexual man (which at no point in my adult life have I ever been) in order to re-contextualize my concerns with their support of right-wing homophobes. It’s […]

  3. UNAPOLOGETIC, By Anne Tagonist, Volume Three, 08/02, Trans Activist Zine From My Collection | Rani Bakr Digs You. - June 30, 2015

    […] mentioned on my detransition post on this blog that I had met trans activist Anne Tagonist. She was a regular at a queer punk get […]

  4. Wish I’d Known @Pink’s Music Converts You To Satan Years Ago, Because That Is Fabulous. | Rani Bakr Digs You. - August 23, 2015

    […] fag hag” vibe I have a ridiculous soft spot for. So yeah my boyfriend at the time (yes that one) and I were really obsessed with Missundaztood-era […]

  5. “STONEWALL WAS BY/FOR WHITE PEOPLE!” – #DropTheT Author Complains To Far-Right Website @FDRLST | Rani Bakr Digs You. - November 9, 2015

    […] but now you’re at best you’re a useless bougie liberal prop for the status quo, and I am and will always be a bigger faggot than you ever […]

  6. Shout Out To A Decade Ago When I Was The Guitarist Of A Pop-Punk Band. | Rani Baker Digs You. - February 29, 2016

    […] upon a time I was a tragically weird, hard-drinking scrawny homo working in a lesbian bar that was about to close down a few months later. I was dating a really […]

  7. Gender Neutral Facilities Aren’t on the Table, but They Should Be – Untamed Wilds - April 5, 2016

    […] A trans woman wasn’t a man up until she came out. She wasn’t even necessarily fully seen as such. Though some may describe themselves as having been male and becoming female, either out of making […]

  8. A Materialist Feminist Study Guide – Materialist Feminist - May 7, 2018

    […] F*ggot As a Gender Identity, Detransition as a Form of Suicide […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: